Advertisement
Finances & Micro-Decisions

Car Ownership vs. Lease Simulator (+ EV Charging ROI)

A complete 5-year Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) model comparing purchasing amortization against closed-end leasing, residual value decay, and electric vehicle fuel parity.

Finances Category Logo
FINANCES // VEHICLE FINANCING & DEPRECIATION

Car Ownership vs. Lease

Compares 5-year purchasing total cost of ownership against 36-month leasing cash outflow.

$
Loan Financing Parameters (Buy)
$
%
Lease Benchmarks (36 Months)
$
%
mi

Financial Verdict & 3-Year Comparison Breakdown

Retained Equity: $6,405.00
Buy Loan Payment
$646.00/mo
60 mo term
Lease Payment
$530.00/mo
36 mo term
3-Yr Equity Kept
$6,405.00
Trade-in value kept
3-Yr Winner
Buying
$117.00 delta
Metric (36 Months)Buy (Loan)Lease (36mo)
Upfront Down Payment$5,000.00$3,000.00
Cumulative Payments (36mo)$23,256.00$19,080.00
Retained Vehicle Equity-$6,405.00$0.00 (Returned)
Net 3-Year Outflow$34,484.00$34,601.00
Verdict: Buying saves $117 because you own $6,405 in trade-in equity after 36 months.
6-YEAR CUMULATIVE NET OUTFLOW (BUY VS. LEASE)

Cumulative Cost Trajectory: Ownership vs. Consecutive Leases

Buy (Net of Equity) Back-to-Back Lease
$0k$22k$44k$10k$9kYr 1$16k$16kYr 2$21k$22kYr 3$25k$31kYr 4$28k$38kYr 5$30k$44kYr 6
ADJACENT VEHICLE TOOL // FUEL & CHARGING ROI

Adjacent Tool: Electric Vehicle (EV) vs. Gas Breakeven & Charging ROI

Find the exact payback distance where charging savings offset the EV price premium.

System:
$

Extra upfront cost of EV before tax credits.

$

Residential rate per kilowatt-hour.

$

Direct input or slide up to $8.00.

Annual Fuel Savings
+$1,143.00/yr
vs. 28 MPG @ $3.65/gal
Annual EV Charging
$617.00/yr
vs. $1,760.00/yr gas
Payback Horizon
Immediate
Tax credit covers premium
5-Year Net ROI
+$6,713.00
5-yr cumulative savings
5-Year Cumulative Fuel vs. Home Electric Charging CostAnnual Fuel Savings: +$1,143.00/yr
$1.8k$0.6kYear 1$3.5k$1.2kYear 2$5.3k$1.9kYear 3$7.0k$2.5kYear 4$8.8k$3.1kYear 5
Advertisement
Independent Decision Science

Methodology, Applied Formulas & Empirical Assumptions

Transparent documentation of the underlying mathematical models, empirical research datasets, and operational boundaries.

Who This Calculator Helps

Prospective car buyers, lessees, and EV shoppers deciding whether a $500 monthly payment represents good financial value once depreciation, financing interest, and maintenance are amortized.

Algorithmic Methodology

Combines non-linear depreciation curves (~20% Year 1 decay, ~54% over 5 years based on empirical automotive industry data), standard amortizing loan debt service formulas, closed-end lease rent factor formulas (Money Factor x 2,400 APR equivalent), and EPA/EIA gasoline ($3.65/gal) vs. residential electricity ($0.16/kWh at 3.5 mi/kWh) parity.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does a car purchase often beat leasing despite higher monthly payments?

At the end of a 36-month lease, you have paid $15,000–$25,000 with zero retained equity. A purchased vehicle retains ~46% of its residual value after 5 years, providing tangible asset equity when sold or driven payment-free.

How does the EV ROI calculator determine breakeven?

It compares annual gasoline expenses ($3.65/gal benchmark at 28 MPG) against residential electricity charging (3.5 miles/kWh at $0.16/kWh) plus federal/state tax incentives ($7,500 benchmark) to project the exact month of cost parity.